‘Ms. Blakk for President’ and the pitfalls of political theater

Issue Two: Ms. Blakk for President
Naveen Kumar
November 16, 2026
Naveen Kumar

Naveen Kumar is a critic at large whose work appears in The New York Times, Town & Country, Variety, and more. He previously served as theater critic for The Washington Post.

Politics is theater. No recent drama has been more fiery or gag-worthy than the campaign trails leading up to the 2026 midterms. Even the ensuing flood of blue-tsunami memes has crashed over the internet like a resounding ovation.

Transforming politics into compelling theater is a tricky prospect, and it’s only grown more so amid the real-world civic mayhem of the past decade. Can anything onstage compete with how bananas it’s all become?

The primary appeal of Ms. Blakk for President, now running at Vineyard Theatre, is that it’s based on a long-overlooked (and rather wild) true story. Co-playwrights Tarell Alvin McCraney and Tina Landau, who also directs, encountered it in a book about LGBTQ+ history in Chicago, where the play was first produced at Steppenwolf Theatre in 2019. The piece follows activist and performer Terence Alan Smith, who made several runs for public office, including for U.S. president in 1992, clad in the drag persona of Ms. Joan Jett Blakk. Wearing a cropped blonde bob that fused punk with executive realness, Ms. Blakk aimed to call out ongoing government inaction to the AIDS crisis and combat homophobia, in the vein of Act Up and an offshoot organization, Queer Nation, that supported her run.

Gideon Glick and Ato Blankson-Wood in Ms. Blakk for President. Photo Credit: Carol Rosegg

Though Ms. Blakk was far from the first presidential hopeful to sport a wig (put some respect on George Washington, y’all), her use of spectacle as a political tool epitomized a tactic intrinsic to queer resistance.

Taking a small paragraph from a niche historical record and turning it into a celebratory piece of theater is the sort of valiant creative gesture that queer history depends on for survival. But capturing the verve and excitement of direct action, and the undercurrents of fury and desperation that fueled them, is a tough hill to climb. Ms. Blakk for President falls short of the summit.

The Vineyard Theatre’s playing space has been reimagined to suggest a nightclub in the round, where we first meet Smith as a work-a-day drag performer, before she swiftly joins an activist group and mounts a campaign for public office. (Scenic design is by David Zinn.) But despite this production’s whirlwind of colors, limbs, and protest slogans, the activity onstage lacks the immediate charge and fascination of the photos and written materials about Ms. Blakk plastered on the lobby walls.

“Drag as politics forces those not blessed with an understanding of ‘gender-fuck’ to deal with the issues of sexual roles and role-playing,” reads one quote attributed to Smith. “What is a man? What makes a woman? Can a man be a woman and still be a man?” Smith asks. “I say yes, yes, and yes! There are no lines anymore; we have stomped on them all.”

A play named for Ms. Blakk that pondered some of these questions, that delved deeper into her character and political awakening, might have been more galvanizing than this more surface account of how her campaign came to be. Played by an unflagging Ato Blankson-Wood, Ms. Blakk neé Smith is a club performer whose influences include Janice Joplin, Tina Turner, and most of all David Bowie. A platonic admirer, played by Gideon Glick, facilitates her move into organizing while her personal motivations for it go largely unexplored.

Though the play’s action is spread across dynamic, interlocking runways, the show’s presentational style — direct-to-audience narration, the recounting of key events — enforces a pageantry-like distance. Ms. Blakk and the ensemble, who variously play her coterie and adversaries (Nic Ashe, Kelvin Moon Loh, Sawyer Smith, and Adina Verson), flit in every direction and even break into sporadic pop music numbers, but rarely does the vibe feel urgent or defiant. The most vibrant moments come and go during a limber and casual pre-show.

Ato Blankson-Wood and Gideon Glick in Ms. Blakk for President. Photo Credit: Carol Rosegg

Part of the problem may be that this chapter in queer history, aside from the particularities of Ms. Blakk’s role, is well-trodden territory both onstage and in pop culture. She is the play’s most magnetic figure, but gets eclipsed as a subject by politics. There is (dare I say it?) a cringe aspect to the earnestness of the arguments articulated here, familiar as they are to many. The subversive spark that ignited grassroots campaigns like these feels subdued and repackaged, canned for consumption.

Other recent shows about AIDS activism have chosen to allow historical records to speak for themselves. Fight Back! from creator David Wise, which will play Under the Radar in January, recreates a 1989 Act Up meeting by handing out scripts and biographical sketches, asking audience members to embody the activists. In Kramer/Fauci, which recently concluded an encore run at St. Ann’s Warehouse, director Daniel Fish dramatized the transcript of a C-SPAN call-in program from 1993, featuring Anthony Fauci and Larry Kramer addressing a Clinton-era AIDS taskforce.

As mundane and in the weeds as such verbatim transcripts may seem in concept, there is an undeniable electricity to the words that were actually spoken, that eventually built momentum and pushed the movement forward.

Of course, the most marginalized voices aren’t often preserved on the record, and imagined history can be a wondrous and transcendent thing. Docu-theater is just one approach, and potentially a privileged one.

The activist milieu surrounding Ms. Blakk’s historic run may be news to some, especially young audiences who rely on pop culture for queer history, since the generation that would have otherwise passed it down perished in devastating numbers. Particulars aside, art with that sort of mission is something sacred.

‍

--

Ms. Blakk for President is playing now through November 29 at the Vineyard Theatre.

‍

Join Our Mailing List

Thank you! More views are coming your way!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
A Project of The Lillys
Web Design and Development by 
‍FAILSPACE Design Services